REVIEW | The Judge (2014)

In the mood for an old-fashioned courtroom and father-son drama? Then here’s your movie.

Chicago hot-shot lawyer Hank Palmer (Robert Downey, Jr.) returns to his tiny Indiana hometown for his mother’s funeral after an unforgivably long time of absence. Suddenly forced to face his estranged father, Joseph Palmer (Robert Duvall)—the town judge— and his brothers, the wary Glen (Vincent D'Onofrio) and the mentally challenged Dale (Jeremy Strong), Hank endures the air of indifference and hostility at home, and just wants to get through the funeral and fly back to his own life. But when the Judge is suddenly accused of murder, it looks like Hank is going to spend more time in this quaint albeit claustrophobic small town and deal with his stubborn father. An old flame (Vera Farmiga) also somewhat complicates his long visit.

“The Judge” surprisingly works despite its moments of overt sentimentality and melodrama. It may have crammed Downey’s prodigal son character with multiple personal stories, too much conflict and emotional burden than what was necessary, but Downey manages to carry the role effortlessly. He is notably impressive whenever he holds back his tears.

The very old Duvall in the first hour or so of the film sometimes stumbles through his lines, frustratingly rusty, but with much relief he eventually disappears into his role as the proud judge who challenges Hank's sensibilities.

“The Judge,” directed by David Dobkin, emotionally connects and aptly incorporates comedic elements, engaging you throughout its 2.5 hours running time. A slightly crude but refreshing small-town drama that will put a lump in your throat—and if you’re a weeper, will make you shed a tear or two.

Billy Bob Thornton also stars.


3.5 out of 5 stars
Opens in Philippine cinemas Oct. 22, 2014

Photo credit: Warner Bros. Pictures